A Focus on Mental Illness: Rejecting the Labels to Respond with Love
A Focus on Mental Illness:
Rejecting the Labels to Respond with Love
[Originally published October 31, 2026]

Hurtful Labels and a Lack of Love
Mental illness impacts the world! Virtually all of us either experience some form of this condition or we know someone who carries the burden of it. I recall numerous pastoral care encounters with beloved church members who shouldered some form of mental illness. Looking back, I wish I had been better equipped to understand, respond, and train others to minister with these dear souls who struggled with the various forms of this malady.
One would think that its prominence would lead to great awareness and empathy, but this often is not the case. It is one of the least understood and most pressing issues of every age, partly because it is not easily recognized; but mainly because it is often misinterpreted and mishandled. [1] For example, labels like “psycho,” “nuts,” “unhinged,” “lunatic,” and “bonkers” reflect hurtful prejudice surrounding this type of affliction and expose the disregard for the value and dignity of those human beings who suffer from such conditions. This global concern leads to a question: How may Christians provide support for those who suffer in this way?
One would think that its prominence would lead to great awareness and empathy, but this often is not the case. It is one of the least understood and most pressing issues of every age, partly because it is not easily recognized; but mainly because it is often misinterpreted and mishandled. [1] For example, labels like “psycho,” “nuts,” “unhinged,” “lunatic,” and “bonkers” reflect hurtful prejudice surrounding this type of affliction and expose the disregard for the value and dignity of those human beings who suffer from such conditions. This global concern leads to a question: How may Christians provide support for those who suffer in this way?
What is “mental illness”?
A mental illness is diagnosed when a person has a group of symptoms (behavioral or psychological problems) that are accompanied by either or both subjective distress or impairment in roles and relationships. [2] Nothing escapes the reach of this form of illness. It disturbs “our thoughts, feelings, and souls, which in turn worsens the mental illness and makes it extremely difficult to figure out what the problem is and what the solutions are.” [3]
The scope of mental illness
One billion people across the globe live currently with a mental health disorder at any given time. Anxiety and depression widely affect people in all countries and communities. This occurrence leads to $1 trillion in indirect costs, mainly because of lost productivity. [4] Mental illness affects 61.5 million Americans annually, which represents 1 in 5 adults. [5] It costs the U.S. economy $282 billion each year, with $126 billion spent on health costs alone. These costs lead to financial strain which further exacerbates depression and anxiety over medical debt.
A large percentage of people with mental illnesses are homeless. Twenty-six percent reside in shelters and live with serious mental illness. When one adds substance abuse disorders to this equation, more than 46% are affected!
According to the Centers for Disease Control, one in six children ages three to seventeen have a "current, diagnosed mental, behavioral, or developmental disorder." Diagnosed conditions include anxiety, Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), Behavior/Conduct Disorders, and Depression.
A large percentage of people with mental illnesses are homeless. Twenty-six percent reside in shelters and live with serious mental illness. When one adds substance abuse disorders to this equation, more than 46% are affected!
According to the Centers for Disease Control, one in six children ages three to seventeen have a "current, diagnosed mental, behavioral, or developmental disorder." Diagnosed conditions include anxiety, Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), Behavior/Conduct Disorders, and Depression.
Types of mental illness
There are two main types of mental illness—mood (affective) and mind (thought) disorders. The former includes anxiety, depression, and bipolar disorders, which are umbrella terms and contain different diagnoses or subclasses. The latter includes schizophrenia and psychosis.
It is highly likely that many people will face mental health obstacles from time to time, but these distresses become an illness when “ongoing signs and symptoms” cause repeated stress and affect a person’s ability to function. Epidemiologists utilize three broad sets of constructs (and combinations of these) to delineate who has a mental illness: 1) “symptoms and signs for each particular mental disorder,” 2) “whether a person has mental health-related difficulties in functioning at school, at work, or at home,” and 3) “whether a person has sought treatment for a mental health condition.” [6]
It is highly likely that many people will face mental health obstacles from time to time, but these distresses become an illness when “ongoing signs and symptoms” cause repeated stress and affect a person’s ability to function. Epidemiologists utilize three broad sets of constructs (and combinations of these) to delineate who has a mental illness: 1) “symptoms and signs for each particular mental disorder,” 2) “whether a person has mental health-related difficulties in functioning at school, at work, or at home,” and 3) “whether a person has sought treatment for a mental health condition.” [6]
Exhausted caregivers and inadequate support
Exhausted family caregivers of those with serious mental illness often live with “a patchwork of care and support services” and the fear for the safety and well-being of their loved one. [7] Sadly, many people with these disorders either refuse available treatments because they deny their illness or because of their disorder (e.g. paranoia). To make matters more difficult, many of the treatments are simply non-effective.
The point
It should be readily apparent that mental illnesses are to be taken seriously and need to be diagnosed and treated by professionals. And while there is some usefulness in quantifying mental illness in the above manner, so much more remains to be done to improve our responses to persons suffering from these disorders. Our awareness does not suffice, nor does it exempt us from caring for and doing what we can to minister to them.
Implications for life's sanctity dignity, freedom, and justice
Life's sanctity. Historically, individuals suffering from mental illness were often confined to asylums for all or a part of their lives (See PeaceWeavers article below). These individuals were many times institutionalized as the hidden and forgotten, which in many ways reduced their life’s value. [8] The 1980s brought deinstitutionalization, and these same people were released from custodial care and often left to live in substandard housing or on the streets (See homelessness above).
Human dignity. Either way, the mentally ill were often robbed of their worth. Better news came, however, when laws like the Americans with Disabilities Act (1990) and the 2006 United Nations Conventions on the Rights of Person with Disabilities were adopted. These establish a foundation for viewing those with disabilities as full members of society with the same rights as all others (e.g. access to health and preventative services). Patients with mental illness, who demonstrate decision-making capacity, have the right to make choices about their health care and claim rights to privacy (i.e. self-determination; inclusive of informed consent). These areas of care help to safeguard their dignity.
Justice. Access to various social programs and adequate mental health care intersects justice because many more than half of the counties in this country do not have a single “practicing behavioral health worker.” One study found that the average wait time to hold an outpatient psychiatry visit was 25 days (Mozes, HealthDay Reporter, 2014). There are less than one practicing psychiatrists worldwide per one million people (cf. between 10 to 70 psychiatrists per 100,000 to 1 million people in the U.S.). The lack of a clear public mental health policy, combined with uneven care, leaves one to wonder whether a way forward may be proposed. Even while this shortage is being addressed, there are things Christians can do to provide care and community for the mentally ill.
Human dignity. Either way, the mentally ill were often robbed of their worth. Better news came, however, when laws like the Americans with Disabilities Act (1990) and the 2006 United Nations Conventions on the Rights of Person with Disabilities were adopted. These establish a foundation for viewing those with disabilities as full members of society with the same rights as all others (e.g. access to health and preventative services). Patients with mental illness, who demonstrate decision-making capacity, have the right to make choices about their health care and claim rights to privacy (i.e. self-determination; inclusive of informed consent). These areas of care help to safeguard their dignity.
Justice. Access to various social programs and adequate mental health care intersects justice because many more than half of the counties in this country do not have a single “practicing behavioral health worker.” One study found that the average wait time to hold an outpatient psychiatry visit was 25 days (Mozes, HealthDay Reporter, 2014). There are less than one practicing psychiatrists worldwide per one million people (cf. between 10 to 70 psychiatrists per 100,000 to 1 million people in the U.S.). The lack of a clear public mental health policy, combined with uneven care, leaves one to wonder whether a way forward may be proposed. Even while this shortage is being addressed, there are things Christians can do to provide care and community for the mentally ill.
Basic first steps toward caring for those with mental illness
Churches should see, listen, and become linked to people with mental illnesses. “Clearly, the ministry of healing — of minds, bodies, spirits, and relationships — was a defining characteristic of early Christianity” [9] Throughout the Gospels, Christ showed compassion for the unwell, some of whom were afflicted with mental disorders and even demon possession (cf. Luke 8:26-39). He cared for people that were social outcasts because of their illnesses, and the Early Church continued this pattern. He healed them and restored them to their families and communities.
The need for genuine Christian care and compassion shown toward the vulnerable, including those with mental illnesses, is a desperate need in our congregations today. This begins by seeing, listening, and becoming linked daily with those who struggle with mental disorders. [10] Churches that care will actively seek to establish helpful, contextualized ministries for those who are laboring beneath the burden of mental illness.
Christians should maintain a core daily commitment to care for those with mental illnesses. The daily commitment to share Christ’s love in human relationships was what led those in the Anabaptist-Mennonite tradition to care for the “weak, injured, sick and dying” in their midst; a tradition that has carried forward to the present (see Mennonite Health Services). Because so many people with mental disorders are falling through the "societal cracks," the Church needs to provide a safety net of community (e.g. Saddleback Church Ministries; see also Mental Health Ministries). The way forward will necessarily include courageous consistency; a virtue all too lacking in modern Christianity. Christians will begin by laying labels aside and offering the genuine love of Christ to these sufferers.
The need for genuine Christian care and compassion shown toward the vulnerable, including those with mental illnesses, is a desperate need in our congregations today. This begins by seeing, listening, and becoming linked daily with those who struggle with mental disorders. [10] Churches that care will actively seek to establish helpful, contextualized ministries for those who are laboring beneath the burden of mental illness.
Christians should maintain a core daily commitment to care for those with mental illnesses. The daily commitment to share Christ’s love in human relationships was what led those in the Anabaptist-Mennonite tradition to care for the “weak, injured, sick and dying” in their midst; a tradition that has carried forward to the present (see Mennonite Health Services). Because so many people with mental disorders are falling through the "societal cracks," the Church needs to provide a safety net of community (e.g. Saddleback Church Ministries; see also Mental Health Ministries). The way forward will necessarily include courageous consistency; a virtue all too lacking in modern Christianity. Christians will begin by laying labels aside and offering the genuine love of Christ to these sufferers.
Taking Up the Cross of Christ
The 1975 Academy-Award winning movie, One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, presented several disturbing themes that helped to raise public awareness toward those with serious mental illnesses. A loss of humanity and dignity and the false belief that mental illness somehow robs persons of their value were two prominent themes in the film. The motion picture demonstrated that both institutions and society were often culpable.
Contrary to this approach, Christians demonstrate a true theology of the cross when we pour out our lives on behalf of those who are weary in mind and soul. Extraordinary challenges lie ahead for those who decide to take up the cross of Christ on behalf of the weakened in our culture, but the “least of these” need us to take hold of the cross with them.
Larry C. Ashlock
Contrary to this approach, Christians demonstrate a true theology of the cross when we pour out our lives on behalf of those who are weary in mind and soul. Extraordinary challenges lie ahead for those who decide to take up the cross of Christ on behalf of the weakened in our culture, but the “least of these” need us to take hold of the cross with them.
Larry C. Ashlock
Notes:
1. Mental illness has occurred and been misunderstood throughout human history. Democritus (460 BCE-370 BCE), who conceived of the soul as body, attributed mental illness to the “excessive hotness or coldness of the fine round atoms that constituted a person’s soul” (Carrick, Medical Ethics in Antiquity, 16). Both the Greeks and Romans discussed the possible blameworthiness of a person who "committed suicide" impulsively without some sort of “sensible reflection.”
In Medieval history, mental illness was attributed, among other things, to a humoral imbalance, lunacy caused by the moon, diabolical possession, and sorcery (Porter, Greatest Benefit to Mankind: A Medical History of Humanity, 127). Prior to WWII there were occasions where the mentally ill were the subjects of experimentation and inhumane treatment (cf. medical schools and human “Guinea pigs”). The 1950s saw the advent of pharmacological approaches to care for the mentally ill and great advances were made. An antipsychiatry movement in the 1960s eventually led to deinstitutionalization of the mentally ill, and the closing of mental hospitals. History records long-standing misunderstanding and mishandling of both those with "mental illnesses" and the general public’s beliefs and responses to this moral issue.
2. Saunders, Stephen M. Christian Guide To Mental Illness Vol 1: Recognizing Mental Illness in the Church & School (p. 46). (Function). Kindle Edition. The formal clinical definition of mental illness is “aspects of a person’s mental life that are not good that reflect a dysfunction in the psychological, biological, or developmental processes underlying mental functioning.” npj Mental Health Research | (2026) 5:11. See Mental Health Research.
3. David Murray and Thomas A. Karel Jr., A Christian’s Gide to Mental Illness: Answers to 30 Common Questions (Head, Heart, Hand Media, 2023). [Kindle Edition. ISBN: 9798285508946]
4. Richard G. Frank, Better But Not Well, 9.
5. See American Psychological Association.
6. See National Alliance on Mental Illness.
7. Insel, NIMH, 2015.
8. Cf. May, “Afflicting the Afflicted: On Total Institutions,” in On Moral Medicine, 516.
9. See Roth, “The Christian and Anabaptist Legacy in Healthcare,” in On Moral Medicine, 128.
10. The Apostles and Early Church offered compassion and community care for those who were ill, including those with mental disorders. The Council of Nicea (325 A.D.) ruled that hospitals to care for the sick were to be established in every cathedral town. In Medieval Belgium, at St. Dymphna at Geel in Flanders, a hospice was built for the mentally ill and when it no longer had room for new residents, many of the mentally ill were lodged in homes throughout the community. This “family colony” was administered by the villagers. All throughout Europe, hospitals, special “cells,” and monasteries sprung up to care for the “insane” (cf. Porter, Greatest Benefit to Mankind: A Medical History of Humanity, 127).
1. Mental illness has occurred and been misunderstood throughout human history. Democritus (460 BCE-370 BCE), who conceived of the soul as body, attributed mental illness to the “excessive hotness or coldness of the fine round atoms that constituted a person’s soul” (Carrick, Medical Ethics in Antiquity, 16). Both the Greeks and Romans discussed the possible blameworthiness of a person who "committed suicide" impulsively without some sort of “sensible reflection.”
In Medieval history, mental illness was attributed, among other things, to a humoral imbalance, lunacy caused by the moon, diabolical possession, and sorcery (Porter, Greatest Benefit to Mankind: A Medical History of Humanity, 127). Prior to WWII there were occasions where the mentally ill were the subjects of experimentation and inhumane treatment (cf. medical schools and human “Guinea pigs”). The 1950s saw the advent of pharmacological approaches to care for the mentally ill and great advances were made. An antipsychiatry movement in the 1960s eventually led to deinstitutionalization of the mentally ill, and the closing of mental hospitals. History records long-standing misunderstanding and mishandling of both those with "mental illnesses" and the general public’s beliefs and responses to this moral issue.
2. Saunders, Stephen M. Christian Guide To Mental Illness Vol 1: Recognizing Mental Illness in the Church & School (p. 46). (Function). Kindle Edition. The formal clinical definition of mental illness is “aspects of a person’s mental life that are not good that reflect a dysfunction in the psychological, biological, or developmental processes underlying mental functioning.” npj Mental Health Research | (2026) 5:11. See Mental Health Research.
3. David Murray and Thomas A. Karel Jr., A Christian’s Gide to Mental Illness: Answers to 30 Common Questions (Head, Heart, Hand Media, 2023). [Kindle Edition. ISBN: 9798285508946]
4. Richard G. Frank, Better But Not Well, 9.
5. See American Psychological Association.
6. See National Alliance on Mental Illness.
7. Insel, NIMH, 2015.
8. Cf. May, “Afflicting the Afflicted: On Total Institutions,” in On Moral Medicine, 516.
9. See Roth, “The Christian and Anabaptist Legacy in Healthcare,” in On Moral Medicine, 128.
10. The Apostles and Early Church offered compassion and community care for those who were ill, including those with mental disorders. The Council of Nicea (325 A.D.) ruled that hospitals to care for the sick were to be established in every cathedral town. In Medieval Belgium, at St. Dymphna at Geel in Flanders, a hospice was built for the mentally ill and when it no longer had room for new residents, many of the mentally ill were lodged in homes throughout the community. This “family colony” was administered by the villagers. All throughout Europe, hospitals, special “cells,” and monasteries sprung up to care for the “insane” (cf. Porter, Greatest Benefit to Mankind: A Medical History of Humanity, 127).
Posted in Pathway Perspectives